Stacking Dependency Parsers
نویسندگان
چکیده
We explore a stacked framework for learning to predict dependency structures for natural language sentences. A typical approach in graph-based dependency parsing has been to assume a factorized model, where local features are used but a global function is optimized (McDonald et al., 2005b). Recently Nivre and McDonald (2008) used the output of one dependency parser to provide features for another. We show that this is an example of stacked learning, in which a second predictor is trained to improve the performance of the first. Further, we argue that this technique is a novel way of approximating rich non-local features in the second parser, without sacrificing efficient, model-optimal prediction. Experiments on twelve languages show that stacking transition-based and graphbased parsers improves performance over existing state-of-the-art dependency parsers.
منابع مشابه
Ensemble Models for Dependency Parsing: Cheap and Good?
Previous work on dependency parsing used various kinds of combination models but a systematic analysis and comparison of these approaches is lacking. In this paper we implemented such a study for English dependency parsing and find several non-obvious facts: (a) the diversity of base parsers is more important than complex models for learning (e.g., stacking, supervised meta-classification), (b)...
متن کاملTraining Parsers on Partial Trees: A Cross-language Comparison
We present a study that compares data-driven dependency parsers obtained by means of annotation projection between language pairs of varying structural similarity. We show how the partial dependency trees projected from English to Dutch, Italian and German can be exploited to train parsers for the target languages. We evaluate the parsers against manual gold standard annotations and find that t...
متن کاملVoting and Stacking in Data-Driven Dependency Parsing
We compare the techniques of voting and stacking for system combination in datadriven dependency parsing, using a set of eight different transition-based parsers as component systems. Experimental results show that both methods lead to significant improvements over the best component system, and that voting gives the highest overall accuracy. We also investigate different weighting schemes for ...
متن کاملStacking of Dependency and Phrase Structure Parsers
We investigate the stacking of dependency and phrase structure parsers, i.e. we define features from the output of a phrase structure parser for a dependency parser and vice versa. Our features are based on the original form of the external parses and we also compare this approach to converting phrase structures to dependencies then applying standard stacking on the converted output. The propos...
متن کاملCross-framework parser stacking for data-driven dependency parsing
In this article, we present and evaluate an approach to the combination of a grammardriven and a data-driven parser which exploits machine learning for the acquisition of syntactic analyses guided by both parsers. We show how conversion of LFG output to dependency representation allows for a technique of parser stacking, whereby the output of the grammar-driven parser supplies features for a da...
متن کامل